Should I Use AI for My Headshot?

AI has found its way into nearly every corner of modern life — from writing and design to photography. One of its latest frontiers is AI-generated headshots, promising professional portraits without the need for a camera, studio, or even a photographer. But when it comes to something as personal as your face, is it really the right choice?

Let’s unpack what people are saying — the good, the bad, and the subtle gray in between.

The Allure of AI: Convenience Meets Technology

AI headshots are, without question, incredibly convenient. For under fifty dollars, you can upload a handful of selfies and receive dozens of polished, professional portraits within an hour. No scheduling, no wardrobe prep, no awkward small talk while trying to pose naturally.

As one Reddit user put it:

“If you’re trying to build trust, AI can backfire. It’s not about how real it looks, it’s about whether people believe it’s you.” — Reddit user, r/photography

That comment captures the tension perfectly. The results can be impressive, even uncanny — but when the goal is to represent who you are, realism alone isn’t enough. You need believability.

For many professionals, the appeal lies in accessibility. AI headshots can make it easier for small business owners, freelancers, or job seekers to present a clean, consistent look across platforms without the time or cost of a photoshoot. It democratizes what used to be a luxury service.

The Missing Ingredient: Authenticity

Still, something’s lost when a portrait doesn’t come from a real interaction.

A good photographer isn’t just adjusting light and angle — they’re drawing out an expression, a confidence, a version of you that feels natural. That kind of connection can’t be coded into an algorithm.

Branding expert Chris Ducker famously said:

“Your personal brand is what people say about you when you’re not in the room.”

That’s what a true headshot represents — the impression you leave behind. AI might create a perfect image, but perfection isn’t always persuasive. Viewers are drawn to authenticity, not flawlessness.

Balancing the Two Worlds

The truth is, both options have their place. AI headshots are practical, fast, and often look great online. Traditional photography, on the other hand, captures you — not just your likeness, but your tone, your energy, your story.

In many cases, the smartest approach is hybrid: use AI for quick updates, mockups, or profile placeholders, and invest in a real photoshoot for your brand’s cornerstone imagery — the one that tells people, this is me.

As I often remind clients:

“A headshot doesn’t just capture your face — it reflects your presence, your promise of professionalism, and your commitment to being seen.”

So, Should You Use AI?

If your priority is speed and simplicity, AI can absolutely get the job done. But if your career relies on personal connection — whether you’re a creative, entrepreneur, or leader — nothing replaces the human touch.

AI can mimic your look, but not your presence.

And when it comes to your professional image, presence still matters most.

Which of these do you think is real — and which one is AI?